Case study
The 100 stands that didn’t fit
When a rushed first batch failed in the client’s hands, we told them the truth, gave them a real choice, and took the loss to make it right. Later that year they reordered 800 more.
Role
Partner, STUCK Design
Period
2024 — 2025
Outcome
All 500 delivered · client reordered 800 more
100
stands in the first batch, none of which fit

Context
Five products, ten suppliers, no formal quality gates.
I run production for the in-store demonstration kits my team designs and makes for global eyewear lens brands. The kits let shoppers see what a lens actually does. Over two years I ran five of these products, made with about ten suppliers in China and shipped to Japan, without formal quality gates. Quality depended on how I ran it.

What failed
We skipped the trial run to hit a date.
One product was a folding stand that holds a lens demonstrator and an A4 display board, held in place by magnetic clasps along the sides. The client needed the first 100 of a 500-stand order quickly for a showcase, so we went to production without trial runs. The prototype had been fine. In production, the material shrank after heat pressing, the clasps came out too short, and the stand could no longer hold its board. The client found it, on all 100 units. We checked the stands ourselves and confirmed it.

The choice
We said it was our mistake, and let them choose.
We were honest that we had rushed. Then we gave them two options: stop here and pay up to 70% of the order, as our terms allowed, or let us finish the order properly at our own cost, one month late. We had run the numbers before we offered. The client was under enormous pressure on that call. My job was to stay calm, promise we would do everything to make it work, and then deliver on that. They chose to let us make it right.

The fix
Keep the showcase alive, then fix the cause.
We heat-stretched the clasps on the first units so the showcase could still go ahead. Then we traced the defect to shrinkage after heat pressing, and retooled the clasps for the rest of the order in about a month. I rewrote the supplier’s QC standard with exact tolerances, plus good and bad videos of the clasp snapping shut, so the factory could see what “right” looks like.

Result
A month and a five-figure loss. Then an 800-stand reorder.
We delivered all 500. Later that year the client reordered 800 more, shipped to China and Japan through 2025, and the account became one of our returning clients. What I took from it: be upfront about risks before they bite. Skipping trial runs to hit a date was a risk the client should have known about when they agreed to the timeline.

Takeaway
Own the mistake early and give the client a real choice. Now nothing goes to production without a trial run and a written QC standard the supplier can check against.
→
Say hi